No Contact Agreement

Recently their state legislature passed amendments (hereinafter “Amendments”) to Pennsylvania’s adoption statutes, within 23 Pa.C.S. Section 2731 et seq, regarding post-adoption contact agreements. Understanding these amendments is vital for any practitioner who handles adoption matters, but it really should be noted that local jurisdiction has procedural idiosyncrasies that must definitely be accounted for when so doing. The Amendments certainly affect adoptions being filed moving forward, but it’s unclear when the Amendments sign up for adoptions filed before passage with the Amendments.

The Amendments are built to provide a statutory basis to make, facilitate the enforcement of, and standardize post-adoption contact agreements. A post-adoption contact agreement is certainly one in which the adopting parent(s) start a contract using the adopted-child’s biological parent(s) and relative(s) to put out the terms and conditions from the biological parent(s) and relative(s)’ contact and/or communication while using adopted-child following adoption from the child is done.

Under the terms in the Amendments, any post-adoption contract (“Contract”) must include four (4) essential elements. First, the Contract need to be in the best interests with the adopted-child. Second, the Contract must indicate recognition with the parties’ interest and desire to have ongoing communication and/or contract with all the child. Third, the Contract’s terms are for being appropriate thinking about the role each party would be to take within the adopted-child’s life after his adoption. Finally, fourth, the Contract is, certainly, governed by the approval with the Court.

Approval from the court will depend on a variety of factors. First, the parties must enter the Contract knowingly and voluntarily plus an affidavit on the same has to be made under oath to affirm a similar and that coercion, fraud, and/or duress played no role from the formation on the Contract. Second, legal court must determine that this Contract need to be in the best interest from the adopted-child. When determining regardless of if the Contract is from the best interests on the adopted-child, the judge may consider factors as follows: “(i) The length of time how the child has become under actual care, custody and charge of a person besides a birth parent as well as the circumstances relating thereto. (ii) The interaction and interrelationship from the child with birth relatives along with persons who routinely interact together with the birth relatives and could significantly change the child’s needs. (iii) The adjustment on the child’s home, school and community. (iv) The willingness and ability in the birth in accordance with respect and appreciate the web link between the child and prospective adoptive parent. (v) The willingness and ability in the prospective adoptive parent to respect and appreciate the text between the child plus the birth relative. (vi) Any proof abuse or neglect with the child.” 23 Pa.C.S. Section 2735(b)(2). A Contract might only be modified by an adoptive parent and/or adopted-child twelve (12) yrs old or older by filing an action while using court that finalized the adoption. A modification may possibly be approved by the Court whether or not this “finds by clear and convincing evidence that modification serves the wants, welfare and interest in the child.” 23 Pa.C.S. 2737(b).

The possible parties to your Contract may also be specifically spelled out by statute. The parties might include the adoptive parent(s) and also so-called “birth relatives.” Birth relatives occasionally includes parents, grandparents, step-parents, siblings, uncles, and aunts. Pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S. Section 2733, siblings within this context add the adopted-child’s blood siblings whorrrre not also being adopted with the adopting parents. In the event how the adopted-child’s siblings are minors and so are to have contact with all the adopted-child post-adoption per a Contract, the minor siblings are to get represented by the guardian ad litem to negotiate the Contract. Finally, even though the adopted-child is technically the topic of a Contract instead of a party, when the adopted-child is twelve (12) years or older, the Contract can’t be ratified unless the adopted-child gives his consent.

The Amendments add notice requirements for that Contract and its particular filing. The requirements for notice are unclear and nebulous. It is notable that while many different birth relatives could possibly be parties for the Contract, just the birth parents have to get given notice and there is no requirement to produce the presumptive father notice. There is also hardly any guidance of how notice is for being provided. The only guidelines provided because of the Amendments for notice is that it has to be provided, and court approved, prior to the entrance with the adoption decree. Furthermore, sufficient time has to be provided towards the birth parents to interact the process of contracting ahead of the expiration on the thirty (30) day period wherein they can revoke their consent for the adoption process.

The Amendments also construct enforcement and discontinuance provisions. The Amendments state rather obviously a Contract are only able to be enforced when it is in compliance with all the terms from the Amendments described above. The Amendments first explain that regardless of if the Contract is violated, the adoption decree can not be set aside on that basis alone. When seeking enforcement, a party may possibly see specific performance with the Contract. A party may possibly seek enforcement from the Contract in the event it same party can be in substantial performance on the Contract which enables it to show by clear and convincing evidence that enforcement serves the wants, welfare, and finest interest with the child.

The Contract’s enforceability terminates per a terms and/or once the adopted-child turns eighteen (18) years, whichever comes first. Finally, the aforementioned constitutes the exclusive and entire remedy available for an event seeking enforcement of an Contract, and “no statutory or common law remedy shall be readily available for enforcement or damages connected with an agreement.” 23 Pa.C.S. Section 2738(f) Alternatively, an adopted-child, upon reaching age twelve (12), may petition the Court for discontinuance with the Contract. A Court might only order discontinuance if there’s clear and convincing evidence which it would serve yourwants, welfare, and interests from the adopted-child. If an event seeks enforcement and/or discontinuance for reasons which can be “insubstantial, frivolous or otherwise advanced in good faith, the legal court may award attorney fees and costs for the prevailing parties.” 23 Pa.C.S. Section 2742.

The above is actually an overview from the Amendments. It is clear that whenever handling an adoption matter, a practitioner need to make sure full compliance with him or her and facilitate, towards the best of his ability, the development and ratification of any post-adoption contact agreement.